We love ours! Daughter loves it because it saves quite a lot of finger pricks. I love it because of the extra data it gives you. Just having the arrow telling you whether the BG is moving up or down makes it worth it in my opinion. For example if you blood tested 4.5 at bedtime then technically that isn't a hypo and you shouldn't do anything. But if you got the same result on a Libre with an up arrow you would know that you didn't need to do anything, with a down arrow it's jelly babies quick!
Yes the accuracy is questionable, but my understanding is that all CGMs have this problem as they are reading interstitial fluid, not blood. So you can't really expect it to be exactly the same as a blood test anyway, and blood tests themselves are not 100% accurate either. We find the Libre reads high at the top end of the scale, low at the bottom end and about right in the middle; if you know that you can work with it. I know that if the Libre is reading in the 3s then daughter almost certainly isn't hypo (although if arrow was pointing down at that level I would treat it as one to stop the drop), if it's in the 2s then she probably is hypo. A 13 on the Libre is usually 11 on the blood test etc. I'm not bothered if the numbers don't match exactly as long as they are in the right area, which they almost always are! I don't think it will ever completely replace finger pricks, we still do them for bolusing purposes (which also serves as a useful check that the sensor hasn't completely lost its marbles), but our use of test strips has gone down by at least half which saves my daughter's poor fingers a bit!
It's also brilliant when you get one of those horrible hypos that takes ages to come back up again, you can just scan instead of having to finger prick loads of times, and as soon as the arrow starts pointing upwards you know you're ok!
I love the graph too, you can see exactly what goes on in between finger pricks, we've had quite some shocks about how high some foods spike the blood sugar! So then you can make decisions about what to do about it if you don't want to be regularly spiking that high.
Maybe we are lucky, but so far we have only had two sensor failures; one because daughter bashed her arm against a door and dislodged it, so not the sensor's fault, and one that just didn't go in right, was starting to fall off after half an hour and we could get no readings from it at all; Abbott replaced that one free of charge. We have found them starting to come unstuck after a few days sometimes, so now we solve that problem by sticking Tegaderm over them, that keeps them stuck and also gives them a bit of extra waterproofing when swimming.
I think how successful the Libre is depends how you are going to use it; if you expect to be able to just swap your blood tester for it then you might be disappointed, but as an additional tool alongside it then it can be very valuable. (I'm clearly a fan but I do however realise that no system is perfect, and there will always be some people who have had a bad experience and wouldn't touch it with a barge pole! That's life I guess 😉)