Low carb: Fat or fiction

Status
Not open for further replies.
pottersusan

pottersusan

Well-Known Member
Relationship to Diabetes
Type 1
apparently we don't need carbs in our diet! Admittedly, life would be easier without them, but...

 
It is my belief that carbs have no nutritional value, on a day to day basis. If I didn't love vegetables so much, I could probably forego carbs.

There's no doubt some of them taste delightful, and they are addictive, but for a T2, who is keen to manage my condition, long term (ideally life-long) without the help of medication, I believe it is in my best interest to significantly reduce my carb consumption, as compared to healthy, non-diabetic individuals.

You do believe we need carbohydrate?
 
Personally I have a problem with both the 'must base every meal on' and 'are completely evil and must all be avoided at all costs' positions.

What I can see is a general shift over time towards a significantly more carb-focussed approach to official health advice in the 1980s (just about the time when our average waistlines started siginificantly expanding). But this is also a period where (well... from the 1970s onwards really) there was a move towards increasingly processed, pre-packaged, convenient, low-effort, beige, e-number filled foods. A huge growth in the power of the food companies, explosion in availability of fast food outlets and a significant cultural shift towards 'every 10 minutes of every day provides a consumption opportunity', where cakes/snacks/treats get ever larger in size. When was the last time your supermarket did 3 for 2 or 50% extra free on veg or salad. How about chocolate, crisps, biscuits, fizzy drinks or cake (or cake bars... or snack bars... or breakfast-replacement flapjacks... or... or...?)

I think Milky Way has a lot to answer for "The sweet you can eat between meals without ruining your appetite". 🙄

Just look at the way most diet plans are advertised on TV - it's all snack bars and puddings.

I absolutely believe that carbs *can* provide a useful, healthy part of a person's diet (with or without diabetes) and there are *some* carbs in virtually everything. As with most things in life it's about moderation in general and treats every so often for me. And finding what works for you as an individual.
 
Last edited:
Personally I have a problem with both the 'must base every meal on' and 'are completely evil and must all be avoided at all costs' positions.
Click to expand...

Exactly.

We might not need carbs, but that doesn't mean you have to exclude them if you don't want to (provided of course you still hit your blood sugar goals).
 
Annette Anderson said:
When Im hypo, I NEED carbs cos a BG of 2.7 and a lump of cheese just isnt going to cut it...:D
Click to expand...

I appreciate in a hypo situation you need to do something fast and easy to metabolise, but in day-to-day living, I don't believe carbs have any nutritional value to us. I certainly don't even attempt to go no-carb (although I know someone who does......................... shudder), as my mounds of vegetables and dairy products will introduce some, in conjunction with required nutrients.

At the moment, I generally run at 50-80gr per day, but these days have no apparent adverse reaction (even watching via the Libre) to a more carby diet. My tastes have just modified and I find the gentle wave much easier to cope with (physically and emotionally) than higher and deeper peaks and troughs. I also believe that for many insulin dependent folks lower carbs = lower insulin requirements with usually (exceptions to all rules, obviously) lead to fewer errors and potentially fewer hypos, requiring fast carb intake.

Of course as someone who has never taken a diabetes med in her life, I realise it's easy for me to spout like this, but it makes for decent discussion/debate. 🙂
 
DeusXM said:
Exactly.

We might not need carbs, but that doesn't mean you have to exclude them if you don't want to (provided of course you still hit your blood sugar goals).
Click to expand...

I couldn't agree more, but for many T2s, who would like to avoid meds or hefty meds that is a real challenge.

Personally, I would rather forego some spaghetti or spuds if it means I don't have to ask my body to metabolise pharmaceutical chemicals.

Of course, that's my choice and doesn't invalidate anyone else's who chooses differently.
 
I couldn't agree more, but for many T2s, who would like to avoid meds or hefty meds that is a real challenge.
Click to expand...

Absolutely - hence why I mentioned blood sugar goals. I personally shoot for under 50g a day. It's actually pretty doable once you get in the right mindset. It's amazing how many carby things in our diet are basically just delivery mechanisms for what we actually want to eat eg. the bread in a sandwich, the rice next to a curry, the bun on the burger.
 
DeusXM said:
Absolutely - hence why I mentioned blood sugar goals. I personally shoot for under 50g a day. It's actually pretty doable once you get in the right mindset. It's amazing how many carby things in our diet are basically just delivery mechanisms for what we actually want to eat eg. the bread in a sandwich, the rice next to a curry, the bun on the burger.
Click to expand...

If I could like this post multiple times, I would.

Who needs rice, when it leaves more room for the garlic chilli chicken, or lamb madras?
 
White carbs are just empty calories 🙄
 
AndBreathe said:
If I could like this post multiple times, I would.

Who needs rice, when it leaves more room for the garlic chilli chicken, or lamb madras?
Click to expand...
I'd go along with that. I eat fairly low carb (<100g) most days cos it suits me to and reduces my risk of hypos due to mismatch of food/digestion/insulin levels). And when I'm feeding myself, it works fine. But at a restaurant. .. I was at a greek place. Asked them to swop the potatoes for a vegetable. Fine, they said. My meal was served with....chips. Aargh!
 
When was the last time your supermarket did 3 for 2 or 50% extra free on veg or salad.
Click to expand...
Umm, yesterday actually. I got soup veg and a green veg mix on three for two. As well as three packs of baby sweetcorn and a twofer on easy peelers.

I do the low carb thing, but perhaps not as 'religiously' as I used to pre re-dx. I've relaxed a little since I went on MDI because things are a lot more stable now. But after 6 years, I find myself feeling all bloated, dopey and really uncomfortable if I have a carb-heavy meal, my body has got used to low carb. I tend to void bread these days because my system can't seem to handle it, pasta is a very rare occurrence and potatoes too (unless it's a hypo day). I do have wild rice more often though and seem to cope very well with that. Barley (in soups) and oatmeal pose no problems for me either. The rest of my carbs come mainly from veggies and small amounts of fruit.

I hope I'm not over-bearing about it when encouraging others to follow the low-carb method. I only push it because it works, at least for me and I'm the original Doubting Thomasina, if I'm not sure something works I'm not gong to say owt.
 
AlisonM said:
Umm, yesterday actually. I got soup veg and a green veg mix on three for two. As well as three packs of baby sweetcorn and a twofer on easy peelers.

I do the low carb thing, but perhaps not as 'religiously' as I used to pre re-dx. I've relaxed a little since I went on MDI because things are a lot more stable now. But after 6 years, I find myself feeling all bloated, dopey and really uncomfortable if I have a carb-heavy meal, my body has got used to low carb. I tend to void bread these days because my system can't seem to handle it, pasta is a very rare occurrence and potatoes too (unless it's a hypo day). I do have wild rice more often though and seem to cope very well with that. Barley (in soups) and oatmeal pose no problems for me either. The rest of my carbs come mainly from veggies and small amounts of fruit.

I hope I'm not over-bearing about it when encouraging others to follow the low-carb method. I only push it because it works, at least for me and I'm the original Doubting Thomasina, if I'm not sure something works I'm not gong to say owt.
Click to expand...

In my observation, Alison, it works for the vast majority of T2s, and many T1s.

Sadly, carbs are addictive, and they can taste nice too, which isn't a helpful coupling if you're trying to give them up. The third thing I find SO (a million times, SO) frustrating is the attitude by some of the medical profession that "diabetics don't want to be bothered to change". Whilst that may be truthful, not do they want to be bother by neuropathy or sight loss. And frankly, unless the options are explained to them, they won't even know what the options are. I have found much of the so-called medical management of my T2 to be just a car-crash. From the advice to go low-fat, to the Eat Well Plate and so on.

Just for the record, the comment that "diabetics don't want to be bothered to change" came from an Endocrinologist, at the tea and biccies (eh?) session, following a local meeting when I asked if he had plans to run patient based trials at the local Diabetes Centre for either the Newcastle Diet or the likes of the David Unwin work - which is just low carb diabetes management, with in-house support.

I just find it incredibly sad that those who like or need to place their absolute faith in our medical profession are being taken down what feels like the easy route, for the medics. That easy route is little dietary change, a few meds and review in a few months time.

My current GP of choice now has an understanding of low carb and when I discussed the Unwin work with her, and left her with the various papers etc., she wanted to propose a trial at our surgery. I had offered to do the data gathering/analysis set up and programme protocol and governance documentation without charge, but the partners weren't interested. This is a practise which reckons diabetes is becoming out of control. The Unwin practise has not raised it's spend on medications for T2 in the last 3 years. I wonder which will have the better future?

Sorry about the rant, but somebody, somewhere has to move eventually from their comfort zone.

(And Alison, I can completely understand why, on a decent MDI regime you might relax your eating regime a little. If I am completely honest, one of the reasons I was evangelic, at diagnosis, about not going on meds was because I felt that if I went down that road, my incentive to practise strict control wouldn't be so great, and I would begin to rely on the crutch. Where you differ is that you have eventually found something that can offer you are more flexible and comfortable life, in the face of other challenges. I think I would probably want to go a bit more relaxed in your shoes, at least for a while.)
 
@AndBreathe. When they thought I was T2, the support I needed was not forthcoming. I found out about low carb here, but when I mentioned it to the GP and a nurse, they said, "no, you need the carbs". This when my numbers had actually started falling after I cut way down on the pesky critturs. After re-dx, I still had the wrong medication and low-carb was one thing that seemed to make a difference. So I've been pretty strict with myself for years because it was the one thing I seemed able to control that helped.

In the few months I've been on MDI, my numbers have been far more stable, I've only had one hypo day and one really bad hypo when they used to be an almost weekly occurrence but now I don't actually want the carbs anymore. That addiction seems to be cured. The one thing I loved and still miss is fresh fruit, I used to eat loads before D, now I have only a little now and again, mostly berries and the occasional orange that I seem to be able to get away with.
 
AlisonM said:
@AndBreathe. When they thought I was T2, the support I needed was not forthcoming. I found out about low carb here, but when I mentioned it to the GP and a nurse, they said, "no, you need the carbs". This when my numbers had actually started falling after I cut way down on the pesky critturs. After re-dx, I still had the wrong medication and low-carb was one thing that seemed to make a difference. So I've been pretty strict with myself for years because it was the one thing I seemed able to control that helped.

In the few months I've been on MDI, my numbers have been far more stable, I've only had one hypo day and one really bad hypo when they used to be an almost weekly occurrence but now I don't actually want the carbs anymore. That addiction seems to be cured. The one thing I loved and still miss is fresh fruit, I used to eat loads before D, now I have only a little now and again, mostly berries and the occasional orange that I seem to be able to get away with.
Click to expand...

Likewise Alison, the thing I might admit to missing is fruit - especially in the tropics where the bananas, pineapples and coconuts grow in the gardens. I know coconut is fine, but it's not high on my list. It comes some way behind banana, sour sop, mango, pineapple and papaya, and a decent crunchy apple. Hey ho. I could I could eat more fruit these days, but fructose is such a nasty blighter, I don't fancy letting too much of it back onto my planet!

You seem so much better than when I first started reading the forum. It must be an enormous relief.
 
Thanks @AndBreathe, I am doing a lot better in many ways. I have a challenging year ahead with yet more investigative appointments and the case conference, plus of course the thrice damned PIP people to deal with. But, I also have some more positive challenges on the crafts side to balance things out. Hopefully they will keep me from sliding back into the pit of depression.
 
AndBreathe said:
Likewise Alison, the thing I might admit to missing is fruit - especially in the tropics where the bananas, pineapples and coconuts grow in the gardens. I know coconut is fine, but it's not high on my list. It comes some way behind banana, sour sop, mango, pineapple and papaya, and a decent crunchy apple. Hey ho. I could I could eat more fruit these days, but fructose is such a nasty blighter, I don't fancy letting too much of it back onto my planet!

You seem so much better than when I first started reading the forum. It must be an enormous relief.
Click to expand...
Actually, I dont miss fruit. I used to eat several pieces a day. Now, its more like 1or 2 a week. And I dont miss potatoes or pasta or rice. The one thing I cant give up is bread. I love my bread. But as I can balance that with insulin, I figure I can get away with it, just in smaller amounts than I used to.
 
Annette Anderson said:
When Im hypo, I NEED carbs cos a BG of 2.7 and a lump of cheese just isnt going to cut it...:D
Click to expand...

Needed for exercise as well. Lump of cheese wouldn't be much good on one of my rides either. 🙂

velo32.gif
 
Matt Cycle said:
Needed for exercise as well. Lump of cheese wouldn't be much good on one of my rides either. 🙂

velo32.gif
Click to expand...

Several athletes use ketogenic diets to deal with their exercise. I can do a day's sailing without carbing up.


Not arguing with you about what you need, just throwing in a counterpoint.

Sorry, I meant to add the video.
 
No problem, it's all very interesting. In my case my BMI is 19.4 (I'm 6' 1 and weigh 67kg) with no excess fat at all - I've always been skinny. I weigh the same now as when I was diagnosed almost 30 years ago and haven't restricted carbs at all or at least only as part of my diet which I would describe as 'balanced.' Being T1 throws up challenges at the best of times but certainly so during exercise and I've found fuelling with carbs work best for me during rides. I would imagine currently that the majority of elite athletes (not that I'm one of them 😉 ) have a carb focussed diet. Whether that will change over the coming years only time will tell. 🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top