Yup - not 'probably due to legislation' - it is SOLELY due to legislation ! But not all companies EVER applied a surcharge for us in the first place. Most of the large composites (eg Sun Alliance, Royal, Commercial Union, Norwich Union, Guardian, Eagle Star ....) did not and about half of Lloyds didn't either. Highway and Equity Red Star definitely didn't. Don't think the Co-op did either. Think you must have been exceedingly unlucky, Matt - to have picked someone that did !!
I worked in insurance all my life and one year my premium shot up (just generally not a surcharge) so I shopped round. The Economic were the cheapest, but including a surcharge. However I did not move it to them. They sent an inspector out to cross examine me. Why?
For the simple reason that at the time another question was also asked on proposal forms (for all classes of business) 'Has any insurer ever applied a surcharge blah blah' - and if you answered 'Yes' then the insurer you were proposing to, would think automatically that there was something iffy about you 'personally' and some companies would refuse to quote at all. Hence - since I did NOT wish to get into THAT scenario* thanks very much - I did not place the cover with them.
* This sort of thing in those days, had future job prospect implications. 'CLUE' (the common claims database) didn't exist till recently - but if you honestly think insurers didn't share info with each other before that - you're fooling yourself.