• Please Remember: Members are only permitted to share their own experiences. Members are not qualified to give medical advice. Additionally, everyone manages their health differently. Please be respectful of other people's opinions about their own diabetes management.
  • We seem to be having technical difficulties with new user accounts. If you are trying to register please check your Spam or Junk folder for your confirmation email. If you still haven't received a confirmation email, please reach out to our support inbox: support.forum@diabetes.org.uk

Exactly same HBA1C test result over 4 months

P

paul.a.thompson

New Member
Relationship to Diabetes
Type 2
Pronouns
He/Him
I've had exactly the same HBA1C result of 55.2 mmol/mol for the last 3 tests over a 4 month period. This seems unlikely has anyone had this happen to them. Particularly as I stopped taking Gliclazide in this period.
 
Statistically it's possible but unlikely. I would raise it with your GPs, or whoever requested the tests, and ask for another one.
 
JITR said:
Statistically it's possible but unlikely. I would raise it with your GPs, or whoever requested the tests, and ask for another one.
Click to expand...
Hi thanks, I've raised with GP and they've agreed a re-test next week. In talking to them they clearly believe that the results are correct rather than something is wrong with the process. Statistically I think the probability of having the same 55.2 mmol/mol result on 7th March, 6th May and 5th Jun is if not zero is pretty close.
 
paul.a.thompson said:
Hi thanks, I've raised with GP and they've agreed a re-test next week. In talking to them they clearly believe that the results are correct rather than something is wrong with the process. Statistically I think the probability of having the same 55.2 mmol/mol result on 7th March, 6th May and 5th Jun is if not zero is pretty close.
Click to expand...
HbA1C is not normally quoted with a decimal point in the result, the test is not that accurate. But whether you would expect the same result in tests that are so close together depends on what you have been doing.
Your march test would be covering Dec, Jan and Feb, the May test covering Feb, March, April and the June test March, April and May so a fair bit of overlap. It is normal to have at least a 3 month gap between tests to reflect changes made.
 
It’s quite unusual to have repeated HbA1c checks so close together because of the ‘overlap’ @leading lights describes.

Some of the reds blood cells from previous tests will still be in circulation during the later results, so a degree of similarity between the HbA1cs is almost to be expected.

HbA1c is slightly ‘weighted’ towards recent weeks, but one of its strengths is that is captures a wider (less immediate) picture.

It’s more common to have HbA1c checks spaced 3-6 months apart 🙂
 
paul.a.thompson said:
Hi thanks, I've raised with GP and they've agreed a re-test next week. In talking to them they clearly believe that the results are correct rather than something is wrong with the process. Statistically I think the probability of having the same 55.2 mmol/mol result on 7th March, 6th May and 5th Jun is if not zero is pretty close.
Click to expand...

The odds of getting three identical credible results results are low but somewhere in amongst all those millions being tested, it will happen to somebody. Could be you are that somebody.

In statistics its called the lottery effect.....the odds of winning the lottery are incredibly low but if you can sell enough tickets, somewhere somebody body will win it.
 
Like @Leadinglights I have not had an HbA1c quoted to a decimal place either, always a whole number. Were these NHS tests or private? It seems very odd indeed both to have 3 HbA1c results quoted to a decimal place as well as them all being identical. If NHS, are you getting them from the NHS app or has the doctor told you the results?
 
A possibility is the tests came out as HbA1c percentages around 7.0% and then converted as such to mmol/mol.
 
everydayupsanddowns said:
It’s quite unusual to have repeated HbA1c checks so close together because of the ‘overlap’ @leading lights describes.

Some of the reds blood cells from previous tests will still be in circulation during the later results, so a degree of similarity between the HbA1cs is almost to be expected.

HbA1c is slightly ‘weighted’ towards recent weeks, but one of its strengths is that is captures a wider (less immediate) picture.

It’s more common to have HbA1c checks spaced 3-6 months apart 🙂
Click to expand...
Hi, I've only recently been diagnosed with Type 2 hence the more frequent tests to check HbA1c was reducing. My results are 126 mmol/mol on 19th Nov, 108 on 11th Dec, 73.8 on the 14th Jan, 55.2 on 7th March, 55.2 on 6th May and 55.2 again on 5th June. The last 3 tests were in order to see the impact of reducing my Gliclazide from 80mg to zero. Given the removal of Gliclazide it is therefore very odd that the HbA1c remained exactly the same. I was wondering if this had happened to anybody else.
 
rebrascora said:
Like @Leadinglights I have not had an HbA1c quoted to a decimal place either, always a whole number. Were these NHS tests or private? It seems very odd indeed both to have 3 HbA1c results quoted to a decimal place as well as them all being identical. If NHS, are you getting them from the NHS app or has the doctor told you the results?
Click to expand...
Hi, the results are from my GP surgery and also on line the test being done by NHS and available on the NHS App.
 
JITR said:
A possibility is the tests came out as HbA1c percentages around 7.0% and then converted as such to mmol/mol.
Click to expand...
Could be the case 7.2% is 55.2. I would however have expected some variation in the percentage value anyway. 7.1% is 54.1
 
Docb said:
The odds of getting three identical credible results results are low but somewhere in amongst all those millions being tested, it will happen to somebody. Could be you are that somebody.

In statistics its called the lottery effect.....the odds of winning the lottery are incredibly low but if you can sell enough tickets, somewhere somebody body will win it.
Click to expand...
Could be the case but the results aren't statistically independent and previous values were 126,108 and 74 add this to my meds being changed between first 55.2 reading and last I would have more chance of winning the lottery. Yours PT B.Sc (Hons) Mathematics.
 
I would bet a small amount of money it's a reporting screw-up.

My instinct is to distrust a lab which reports HbA1c in mmol/mol with a spurious decimal point.
 
Whatever the reason for the three identical results, and if it is assumed that they are in the right ball park, some congratulations are due with respect to the overall drop in HbA1c that you have achieved since November. What approach did you use?

When I stopped taking gliclazide on DN's advice I noticed a small but distinct increase in blood glucose levels all round. Might be the same for you but as with most things diabetes you need to take care when predicting things.
 
It looks to be a positive result to maintain a steady level when you have stopped taking one of the medications. If you are not taking gliclazide then you have more options to reduce your carb intake to drop your HbA1C down a bit more.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top