Just catching up with this thread with interest.
It was a great disappointment to me that the new NICE guidance for type 2 did not support SMBG for the avoidance of
hyperglycaemia. In fact I could not find a section that recommended target levels for pre/post meal BGs at all any more. I wish the patient reps on the Guideline Development Group had been experienced self-testers and/or had been able to put the case for active D&E management more clearly - as many of our members could clearly have done.
This new NICE T2 guidance had quite a difficult birth and its publication was put back because of some significant and potentially dangerous problems with some of the recommendations that were identified when it went out for consultation. Various bits were then re-drafted I think.
Interestingly, one of the people on the Guideline Development Group for this guidance was Andrew Farmer - some long-term members may remember a 2009 paper 'Farmer et al' which found benefit in SMBG for glycaemic control in some, but had concerns over people getting depressed when they were just told to take BGs and not what to do with the results (surprise surprise!). The more intensive group were aiming to 'maintain adherence to a healthy lifestyle', rather than specifically adjust food choices base on pre vs post meal BGs I think.
While the data do not exclude the possibility of a clinically important benefit for specific subgroups of patients in initiating good glycaemic control, SMBG by non-insulin-treated patients, with or without instruction in incorporating findings into self-care, did not lead to a significant improvement in glycaemic control compared with usual care monitored by HbA1c levels
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19254484 - Basically he'd already made his mind up.
Meanwhile more recently I have seen this research:
Scientists have released new results underscoring the importance of a personalized diet, prepared based on complex factors such as your gut microbes and lifestyle. Surprisingly[sic!], the foods that raise blood sugar levels differ dramatically from person to person.
http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2015/11/151119143445.htm
And this:
https://www.mja.com.au/journal/2015...sely-when-it-comes-monitoring-type-2-diabetes
Essentially showing that *structured* SMBG in people with T2 (whether on meds or not)
works. Structured, in this case being testing before a meal and, say 2 hours after a meal... then reviewing food choices based on that . Sound familiar?!
Sorry to derail the thread with all this technical stuff, but hope some find it interesting.