Hi, i am due an upgrade from my accu chek insight pump and have been offered the omniod dash or medtronic 640g. I dont really know much about either of them. With my insight i stash the pump in my bra and use the handset. I work a pretty active job, im a vet care assistant working nights and i run and play netball. Any pros/cons to either??? Ive not really had any info from my diabetes team. I have ordered the trial pod to see what its like.
-
Please Remember: Members are only permitted to share their own experiences. Members are not qualified to give medical advice. Additionally, everyone manages their health differently. Please be respectful of other people's opinions about their own diabetes management.
Omnipod dash vs Medtronic 640g
- Thread starter Helz
- Start date
- Status
PattiEvans
Well-Known Member
- Relationship to Diabetes
- Type 1
- Pronouns
- She/Her
Hi Helz
I wonder if you are in the same neck of the woods as I am (Cornwall) as my clinic give the same choice of pumps. 4 years ago when I got my replacement pump the clinic had stopped offering the Insight as they'd had a lot of trouble with it, Animas had gone out of the scene and so my choice was the Medtronic or another AccuChek Combo. I had met up with another pump user on the Medtronic and we'd discussed it in detail. I didn't like the idea of having to fish the Medtronic out of my clothing to bolus as I had become used to the handset. OK when I'm wearing trousers or skirts with a pocket, but not so good when wearing a dress. So I have had another 4 years on the Combo. I've pretty much made up my mind to have the Omnipod in November this year. I also tried out the trial pod and you soon forget it's there.
I wonder if you are in the same neck of the woods as I am (Cornwall) as my clinic give the same choice of pumps. 4 years ago when I got my replacement pump the clinic had stopped offering the Insight as they'd had a lot of trouble with it, Animas had gone out of the scene and so my choice was the Medtronic or another AccuChek Combo. I had met up with another pump user on the Medtronic and we'd discussed it in detail. I didn't like the idea of having to fish the Medtronic out of my clothing to bolus as I had become used to the handset. OK when I'm wearing trousers or skirts with a pocket, but not so good when wearing a dress. So I have had another 4 years on the Combo. I've pretty much made up my mind to have the Omnipod in November this year. I also tried out the trial pod and you soon forget it's there.
ypauly
Well-Known Member
- Relationship to Diabetes
- Type 1
I had 2 combos over an 8 year period but had to change and foolishly picked the medtronic 640g, the pump itself is OK but getting supplies or any kind of service has been a nightmare, I am only 8 months into a 4 year contract and already considering injecting again
Anybody else have supply issues?
Anybody else have supply issues?
I don't have any experience of either of the pumps mentioned but I thought my experience of tubey vs tubeless which may be of interest and something to consider.
I was an Animas user for 4 years and loved the flexibility that it gave me but hated the size and hated that it was always on show. When Animas pulled out of the insulin pump market, I was offered the Medtronic. I think, 640G. It was even bigger than the Animas and still had no remote control.
OmniPod was not on offer as my CCG considered it too expensive. But I made a bit of a fuss and was offered the chance to be a guinea pig for the then new Medtrum - a tubeless/patch pump with a remote control.
So my thoughts of tubed vs tubeless are
- The tubey pump has only the cannula attached to my body. All of the tubeless pump is attached which means a larger flat area is required and there are less options to move sites.
- Being, effectively, on a tether, the tubey pump can move around where as the tubeless pump is fixed in place untill you change it. This means I have to plan ahead if I may be climbing to ensure I avoid where my harness sits or what I am going to wear in case I need to be concerned about a bulge which cannot move.
- The tubeless pumps are smaller so more discrete.
- The tubey pump can be temporarily removed when you have a sauna or an x-ray, for example. A tubeless pump has to be completely removed and started from scratch.
- I was always able to tuck my tube in so didn't have the risk of catching it on a door handle but I know others have struggled. There is nothing to worry about with a tubeless pump.
- The cannulas are separate to the pump for a tubeless pump. Therefore, you have flexibility to chose the angle, length, composition to suit your body. With a tubeless pump the cannula/needle is an integral part of the pump. You have no choice.
- Having a remote control (now, I just use an app on my phone but I don't know whether the OmniPod has this) is wonderful. I never have to fish my pump out, can review my settings, give myself a bolus, adjust my basal on the app. I feel I am more in control now because it is so much less effort to notice I am going high and give myself a correction or notice I m going low and suspend my basal.
There are pros and cons of both but I am pleased I pushed for a tubeless pump.
I was an Animas user for 4 years and loved the flexibility that it gave me but hated the size and hated that it was always on show. When Animas pulled out of the insulin pump market, I was offered the Medtronic. I think, 640G. It was even bigger than the Animas and still had no remote control.
OmniPod was not on offer as my CCG considered it too expensive. But I made a bit of a fuss and was offered the chance to be a guinea pig for the then new Medtrum - a tubeless/patch pump with a remote control.
So my thoughts of tubed vs tubeless are
- The tubey pump has only the cannula attached to my body. All of the tubeless pump is attached which means a larger flat area is required and there are less options to move sites.
- Being, effectively, on a tether, the tubey pump can move around where as the tubeless pump is fixed in place untill you change it. This means I have to plan ahead if I may be climbing to ensure I avoid where my harness sits or what I am going to wear in case I need to be concerned about a bulge which cannot move.
- The tubeless pumps are smaller so more discrete.
- The tubey pump can be temporarily removed when you have a sauna or an x-ray, for example. A tubeless pump has to be completely removed and started from scratch.
- I was always able to tuck my tube in so didn't have the risk of catching it on a door handle but I know others have struggled. There is nothing to worry about with a tubeless pump.
- The cannulas are separate to the pump for a tubeless pump. Therefore, you have flexibility to chose the angle, length, composition to suit your body. With a tubeless pump the cannula/needle is an integral part of the pump. You have no choice.
- Having a remote control (now, I just use an app on my phone but I don't know whether the OmniPod has this) is wonderful. I never have to fish my pump out, can review my settings, give myself a bolus, adjust my basal on the app. I feel I am more in control now because it is so much less effort to notice I am going high and give myself a correction or notice I m going low and suspend my basal.
There are pros and cons of both but I am pleased I pushed for a tubeless pump.
- Status