Conflicting advice...who is right?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Jennyclaire

Member
Relationship to Diabetes
Type 2
Hello, I have recently been diagnosed as type 2, I've been told to control sugar levels by diet for 3 months and the nurse will check in December to see if there is any improvement. I haven't been given any dietary information and have to go on a Desmond course before I can see a dietician. I would like to make a head start and so have started cutting out sugary things and eating more carbs with slow sugar release but I've read lots of conflicting information saying you can have carbs and then some internet sites saying you can't. I'm so confused!! I've started following a low gi diet but want to know if carbs are ok or not. Does anyone have any ideas....many thanks for reading. 🙂
 
It's very individual Jenny - but the fact remains that we all have a condition that results in our bodies being unable to cope properly and in a timely manner, with converting carbohydrates into 'fuel' for the cells.

Some people's bodies cope very well by eating 'slower release' carbs Some people don't so they will try 'curbing the carbs' which is quite sensible under the circumstances.

It's a little known fact that our bodies don't actually need ANY starchy (ie very fast release) carbohydrate and most of the NHS will argue till death that that is incorrect and the one thing we MUST eat is plenty of flipping starch. The reason we don't need it, is because the fuel the cells esp the brain use, is actually glucose, not carbohydrate. And the body can make glucose out of carbs, protein and fat. However compared to carbs, the protein will only produce 50% of the glucose the same amount of carb would, and fat 10%. So you can 'low carb' to your heart's content and none of you will die from that!

The only things you'll see in consequence usually are 1. weight loss and 2. a lowering of your lipid levels - because carbs cause that to be increased, especially the LDL cholesterol level which they are all so very fond of prescribing statins more statins and higher dose statins to fight. Why take a pill (which has some not very nice - changing quality of life - side effects for about 10% of patients)

The only way you'll know what's OK for you to eat and what isn't is to get yourself a blood glucose meter and the test strips and test before and after you eat, noting the foods that have unwanted effects on your blood glucose. You may not have to cut them out entirely, it may be that you could just eat less of those ones and do fine. A 3 monthly HbA1c blood test won't tell you THAT.
 
As TW says diabetes is an individual thing, what works for one may not work for some one else. You will no doubt getting conflicting opinions I had my annual review last week and they rattled of a list of foods to eat, and the majority of them would send my BS sky high and some I can't stand and if I did eat them would send my BS high again.

Getting a meter is very good advice as you can start to identify what foods effect you and in what way. The big problem is getting the test strips on prescription as most GP practices say type 2's don't need to test.

If you can't get test strips on prescription there are a few lower cost self funding options like the SD code free which has strips at around ?7 per pot of 50 strips.

Meters like Bayer, Abbot, Accu Chek, Lifescan etc you normally can get for free by ringing them or filling in their on line request forms, as they make their money off the test strips.
 
I'm a low GI dieter too. I read a lot and got advice from folk on here because it quickly became clear that the medical experts I was dealing with were stuck in the dark ages. Even after my diagnosis was changed I kept up with the low GI thing because, frankly, I feel better.

Testing is another bug bear. T2s are rarely encouraged to test at all but it's an incredibly useful tool that can provide vital information about what foods affect you most. Without that information the battle is much harder than it needs to be. My advice to you is to buy yourself a meter an strips and start testing whenever you eat to establish what is safe for you, what you can have sometimes and what you really should avoid. For many, the things to avoid are the complex carbs contained in things like white bread, pasta, rice and spuds. Some cereals can be problematical too, although there seems to be much more variation in our reactions to them. For instance, I can't handle Weetabix but am fine with oatmeal while others find the opposite is true for them. It's a case of test and see.

Welcome to the forum.
 
Go to your library; there will be several books on diabetes and the diabetes diet. they may not be for your precise condition, but they will be much better than trying to manage on your own, and also be useful background reading and get you used to the terms and expressions used

Join Diabetes UK. They have a newly diagnosed welcome pack full of advice including diets

020 74241000
www.diabetes.org.uk
 
It's worth noting that DUK recipes are on the whole NOT low-carb!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top